A Missoula judge appointed by former Democratic Governor Steve Bullock has temporarily blocked a newly enacted law that protects women’s bathrooms and locker rooms from being accessed by biological males.
District Court Judge Shane Vannatta, who openly identifies as a member of the LGBTQ community, issued a ruling Wednesday putting the law on hold just days after it was signed by Governor Greg Gianforte. The law, aimed at safeguarding the privacy and safety of women and girls, ensures that public restrooms and facilities in government buildings are used based on biological sex rather than gender identity.
Judge Vannatta, siding with five plaintiffs who challenged the law, claimed the measure could violate the Montana Constitution’s equal protection clause and alleged that it was “motivated by animus.” He further argued that the law lacks evidence of enhancing women’s safety — a claim critics argue ignores both common sense and public concern.
The judge’s temporary order will remain in effect until at least April 21, when a hearing will be held to determine whether the law should remain blocked during ongoing litigation.
Governor Gianforte’s office defended the legislation, with spokesperson Kaitlin Price stating, “We’re not surprised to see far-left activists run to the courts to stop this common sense law. A man shouldn’t be in a women’s restroom, shouldn’t be in a women’s shower room and shouldn’t be housed in a women’s prison.”
The law is part of a broader effort by Montana Republicans to protect women’s privacy, particularly in spaces where biological differences matter — such as bathrooms, locker rooms, and correctional facilities. Supporters argue the law is a necessary safeguard in a time when women’s rights and safety are being undermined by radical gender ideology.
By: DNU staff