• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Digital News Updates
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business

Montana Supreme Court Orders New Environmental Review for Laurel Gas Plant While Allowing Operations to Continue

January 4, 2025

In a closely watched decision Friday, the Montana Supreme Court ruled that state regulators failed to conduct an adequate environmental review of NorthWestern Energy’s Laurel natural gas plant. The ruling, shaped by the court’s liberal-leaning majority, requires the Montana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) to revisit its evaluation of greenhouse gas emissions but allows the plant to continue operating.

The 175-megawatt Yellowstone Generating Station, which began generating electricity in March 2024, has been embroiled in legal battles for years. The court’s decision upheld a 2023 ruling by Yellowstone County District Court Judge Michael Moses, who found that the DEQ failed to properly account for the climate impacts of the plant’s emissions.

The seven-member court was divided in its decision. A plurality of three justices—Beth Baker, Mike McGrath, and James Jeremiah—crafted the lead opinion, mandating a more thorough environmental review while stopping short of revoking the plant’s operating permit. Justices Laurie McKinnon and Ingrid Gustafson, both known for their progressive liberal stances, argued for an even stricter approach, contending that the permit should be revoked until the environmental review is completed. Meanwhile,  Justices Dirk Sandefur and Jim Rice concurred with letting the plant operate but resisted the call for a more extensive review.

Radical environmental groups hailed the ruling as a step forward in holding the state accountable for addressing climate change.

“This decision is long overdue,” said Anne Hedges of the Montana Environmental Information Center. “The climate crisis has damaged our economy, rivers, and air quality, yet the state and NorthWestern Energy continue to ignore the impacts. While this doesn’t solve the problem for neighbors living next to a polluting plant on the Yellowstone River, it forces the state to hit the reset button and acknowledge the harm we’re experiencing from burning fossil fuels.”

The decision echoes the court’s recent ruling in the landmark Held v. Montana case, where the court sided with youth plaintiffs advocating for their constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment. That case challenged a 2023 law, House Bill 971, which limited the scope of environmental reviews for projects like the Laurel gas plant.

The Laurel plant case was brought to court by the Montana Environmental Information Center and the Sierra Club, who argued that the DEQ’s initial permit approval failed to account for the plant’s contribution to global warming.

By: DNU staff

Filed Under: Featured, Home Featured, News

Related Articles:

  • Governor Gianforte Announces Board Appointments
  • Lawmakers propose legislation to prevent China’s global military expansion
  • Buckskin Mine Honored with 2025 DEQ Excellence in Mining Reclamation Award
  • Poll: College not preparing students for workforce, managers avoid hiring them
  • In just a few months, ICE makes 1,000+ worksite enforcement actions
  • Senate Committee Advances North Dakota Superintendent Baesler’s Nomination for Federal Education Post

Primary Sidebar

Digital News Updates Logo

Recent News Posts

  • Law enforcement agencies in 40 states are partnering with ICE 287(g) program
  • Gallatin College MSU’s online courses expand to meet nontraditional student needs
  • UM Video Game Team Scores National Championship
  • In just a few months, ICE makes 1,000+ worksite enforcement actions

Recent Politics Posts

  • Watchdogs: New Montana law restricting foreign money in elections insufficient
  • Knudsen Urges Gallatin County to Support ICE Partnership
  • Zinke Introduces Bipartisan Bill to Modernize Foreign Military Sales Notification Process
  • Senator Daines Introduces Bill to Keep National Cemeteries Open on Federal Holidays

Recent Business Posts

  • Poll: College not preparing students for workforce, managers avoid hiring them
  • Bridger Aerospace Lands Record-Breaking Wildfire Contracts for Super Scooper Aircraft
  • Daktronics to Participate in Craig-Hallum’s 22nd Annual Institutional Investor Conference
  • Montana Expands Conduit Bond Financing

Copyright © 2025 Digital News Updates, All Rights Reserved.