• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Digital News Updates
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Business

Manhattan DA Argues Supreme Court Ruling on Presidential Immunity Doesn’t Affect Trump’s Conviction

July 28, 2024

Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s office has filed a brief asserting that a recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling on presidential immunity does not impact the criminal case against former President Donald Trump. The July 24 filing states that the Supreme Court’s decision “has no bearing on this prosecution” and does not warrant overturning the jury’s unanimous verdict or dismissing the indictment.

The Supreme Court’s ruling, issued earlier this month, affirmed that while presidents have absolute immunity for core constitutional functions and presumptive immunity for official acts, they do not have immunity for unofficial acts. Chief Justice John Roberts clarified that communications between a president and aides cannot be used to determine if an act was official.

Following this ruling, Trump’s defense team requested that New York Supreme Court Justice Juan Merchan dismiss both the indictment and the guilty verdict in his Manhattan case, arguing that communications between Trump and his aides, which they claim were central to the grand jury’s indictment and the jury’s verdict, were improperly used as evidence.

In response, prosecutors contend that the charges against Trump are based on “unofficial acts” that fall outside the scope of presidential immunity. They emphasize that the contested evidence represents only a small fraction of the extensive testimony and documentary evidence considered by the jury, and therefore, does not justify dismissing the case.

Prosecutors argue that the defense failed to preserve a proper record of objections based on presidential immunity, which prevents the court from considering these claims. They also point out that objections related to presidential immunity were not raised during the trial but only after the Supreme Court’s ruling.

Earlier, Trump’s attorneys had challenged the admissibility of testimony from White House Communications Director Hope Hicks and Oval Office Director of Operations Madeleine Westerhout, who provided evidence that Trump signed checks at the White House. Justice Merchan had overruled these objections, and additional evidence, including social media posts by Trump, was admitted despite defense objections.

Prosecutors argue that even without the contested evidence, the grand jury’s indictment is supported by ample remaining evidence. They state that the records involved include 34 counts of falsifying business records, specifically detailing 11 checks to Trump’s former attorney, Michael Cohen, and associated invoices.

Justice Merchan is expected to rule on the presidential immunity arguments before the scheduled sentencing for Trump on September 18.

By: DNU staff

Filed Under: News

Related Articles:

  • Montana State chemist receives Camille Dreyfus Teacher-Scholar Award
  • Officials Urge Caution on Roads as “100 Deadliest Days of Summer” Begin
  • Wyoming Business Council Charts Bold Path Forward for State’s Economic Future
  • Wyoming Public Safety Communications Commission to Meet May 28–29 in Casper
  • Montana State professor Elizabeth Shanahan receives Fulbright Scholar Award for research in Australia
  • Gianforte Launches Fifth Annual 56 County Tou

Primary Sidebar

Digital News Updates Logo

Recent News Posts

  • Judge halts order to terminate Harvard foreign student visas
  • Wyoming Public Safety Communications Commission to Meet May 28–29 in Casper
  • Wyoming Veterans Commission Concludes First-Ever Veteran Services Symposium in Casper
  • Public Comment Open for Draft Idaho Mountain Goat Management Plan Through June 8

Recent Politics Posts

  • Knudsen Urges Gallatin County to Support ICE Partnership
  • Zinke Introduces Bipartisan Bill to Modernize Foreign Military Sales Notification Process
  • Senator Daines Introduces Bill to Keep National Cemeteries Open on Federal Holidays
  • Zinke Votes to Pass “Big Beautiful Bill”

Recent Business Posts

  • Bridger Aerospace Lands Record-Breaking Wildfire Contracts for Super Scooper Aircraft
  • Daktronics to Participate in Craig-Hallum’s 22nd Annual Institutional Investor Conference
  • Montana Expands Conduit Bond Financing
  • Bill Ackman’s Pershing Square Invests $900 Million in Howard Hughes Holdings

Copyright © 2025 Digital News Updates, All Rights Reserved.